Hi Commander drivers, owners & aficionados.
I'm Peter Bichier, I don't have a Commander but I grew up around them, I would like to operate/fly one some day. Until that happens, I would like to learn as much as I can on them. Right now I'm not going to talk too much about me or my Dad's 1955 straight 560 s/n211 (YV-T-ABE) because I should be working instead on being here, but Jim's accident has really been itching me so I'm bringing up the issue. (I promise I will follow up on my introduction at some point).
Meanwhile, I would like to start to discuss what could have happened to N222JS. I fly small single engine taildraggers, and if I have it made it to base or final I have enough energy to make it to the strip without adding any power. I know with the gears engines you don't really cut power completely but then that should actually help you if the engine quits; you might be short of the runway, but you wouldn't shoot up in the sky and stall (specially knowing it's Jim Bob behind the wheel and for those who don't know him he is not your typical Sunday driver).
Here is what I have gathered so far:
The preliminary NTSB report on Jim's accident. Keith and EVERYONE else, what on earth could have happened? He was seen making a right downwind & base for 28R (engines sounded normal) and then a "witness" (from NTSB) saw: "A witness on the airport reported that they observed the airplane approaching the runway about 75 feet above the ground. They saw the airplane descend to about 50 feet, then climb back up to about 75 feet when it suddenly made a hard right turn and descended into the ground near the taxiway.
So apparently something made him climb at the last moment and then stalled (no comment about engine noise), this is clearly not JimBob's style to say the least, one of the most experienced Commander pilot I've flown in this country. Could it be a stroke? collapsing and then pulling the yoke?
Morris, is there a way mechanically to block the elevator up if something breaks? Right engine does not seem to have been turning (seeing the pictures), but if he lost the Right making a right turn could have affected his attitude, but again this is an experienced AG pilot with 340HP to get out of that situation... I'm totally confused and most likely the winner of next year's GOLDEN Pedal Award won't even remember what happened...
We know Jim is a fighter and he seem to be on the long road to recovery, meanwhile here are some links including at the end the LIVEATC.net recording of Jim (only hear the tower comm.) nothing abnormal beside ATC first not been able to pick up 222JS transponder and then having difficulties hearing his altitude.
http://www.ntsb.gov/_layouts/ntsb.aviation/brief.aspx?ev_id=20150923X41349&key=1http://www.kathrynsreport.com/2015/09/aero-commander-680-e-n222js-accident.htmlhttp://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/wiki.php?id=179770 http://www.liveatc.net/search/?icao=KBOIRemember to search KBOI 09/21/2015 for 2200Z time slot and he shows up at 11:05 after the hour, at 16:25 he is "cleared to land" and at 18:23 "Tower, did you see that airplane going down?
Thanks Glenn, Adam, Russell, Nico and whom ever is involved in modifying this new site, I'm looking forward to read and interact more with the Commander world.
Jim Bob: hang in there! (Sue thanks for keeping us so well informed)
PS: I tried to attach the MP3 but came with an error "413 Request Entity Too Large" it's 3.8 Megs how do I attach then?